Welcome our second Meta Monday thread! We needed to enhance communication between the moderator group and the customers of /r/games in an effort to enhance the subreddit as a complete. To that finish, we've established the Meta Monday threads. We’ll endeavor to run these Meta Monday threads at the least as soon as a month to solicit suggestions about a facet of /r/games that we’ve issues about. We might make the most of this suggestions in making modifications that may hopefully enhance the subreddit in the long term.
Bulletins of Bulletins
Over time we’ve seen suggestions relating to submissions which are "bulletins of bulletins". Listed here are a couple of examples:
- Danganronpa creator Kazutaka Kodaka to announce new title on December 9
- Toydea to announce new RPG and eSports titles for PS4, Switch, PC, and smartphones at TGS 2019
- Atlus USA to Make Persona 5 Royal Related Announcement on Tuesday December 3, 2019
The suggestions we frequently see for this sorts of submissions is that they aren't information or aren't offering any worthwhile dialogue. What are your ideas on bulletins of bulletins? Do you discover worth in submissions like these? Tell us!
Nothing main to announce right here truly. We've simply up to date a number of the verbiage of our guidelines to be extra clear on what they cowl.
3.1 No off-topic content material or feedback – Submissions must be instantly associated to video games or the gaming business. Prime degree feedback have to be on matter. Decrease degree feedback must be fairly associated to the dialogue. The next matters fall beneath this class and are higher suited on different subreddits:
- Movie or tv adaptions of video games
- Online game retail objects similar to attire, toys, and collectibles which don’t have any interplay or integration with a sport
- Particular person e-sports participant or sport streamer information
- Profession recommendation
- Information relating to sport live shows
Please notice that the above record is NOT complete and different content material could also be thought of off-topic and shall be eliminated at mod discretion.
This rule has been up to date to incorporate a listing of a number of the content material we take into account to be off-topic. We’ve got obtained plenty of suggestions about offering a listing of off-topic topics for higher submission steerage so we’ve included a listing of a number of the greater quantity matters we take away. This record just isn’t complete, and we might add objects to it over time for extra readability. To be clear – we’re not altering what we take into account to be off matter, we’re simply making a few of these objects extra seen now.
6.Eight No hyperlinks to particular person gross sales, solely gross sales occasions or free sport occasions – Hyperlinks on to a retailer web page or announcement relating to a person sport happening sale (e.g. sport is 30% off) will not be allowed. Nonetheless, hyperlinks to sale occasion bulletins (e.g. Steam Vacation gross sales, Humble Bundles, flash gross sales, and many others.) are permitted, as are hyperlinks to free sport occasions (e.g. Free weekends, Video games With Gold, PS Plus Free Video games, and many others). Free sport occasions are thought of to be cases the place video games that are usually offered are both briefly free or transitioned to completely free. One submission is permitted for a pre-announcement of a gross sales/free sport occasion in addition to a submission notifying that the occasion has began. Submissions relating to individually discounted video games are extra acceptable in subs similar to /r/GameDeals.
The updates to Rule 6.Eight are principally a facelift – the spirit of the rule has all the time been to forestall flooding of the subreddit with spam about reductions for video games which come and go on an hourly foundation. Within the earlier wording we known as out exceptions to this rule which have been gross sales occasions, Humble Bundles free video games, or free weekends for video games. We up to date this rule to make clear that any free sport occasions are permitted within the subreddit and we offered extra examples that are a bit extra fashionable. With this replace we additionally offered a definition of what we take into account to be a "free sport occasion" in addition to limitations to bulletins of those occasions.
Rule 8 – Account Historical past Requirement – Not more than 10% of your submissions throughout all of Reddit could also be to any single web site, profile, channel, or on any given matter. This isn’t restricted to your personal content material: you will be in violation of the promotion guidelines for a web site that you haven’t any direct affiliation with. Feedback normally don’t issue into the 10% rule. That being stated, we will take feedback into consideration if we really feel they’re getting used to avoid the 10% submission restriction (similar to posting a selected area repeatedly in feedback).
Very slight replace/correction right here. Round 4 months in the past we had a big rule overhaul lined here. In our revamp, we by accident made Rule Eight much less specific. The rule used to state that the 10% restrict took into consideration websites and matters, however in our revamp this was altered to say "single web site or on any profile/channel". This wording has been corrected to replicate we nonetheless consider extreme promotion of a single matter.
Earlier Meta Monday
Final Meta Monday we mentioned Player Counts & Sales Numbers Threads. Admittedly, participation was not as excessive as we have been hoping and the opinions on these specific threads appear to be quite cut up on each ends of the problems so at the moment we wouldn’t have any info to share relating to coverage updates on a majority of these threads. Nonetheless, we are going to name out how we presently take care of these:
Gross sales threads are presently permitted so long as unique sources are linked to per Rule 6.1. Exceptions for this are when gross sales figures are given in a format such a convention name which has not been transcribed, when the figures will not be accessible in English, or when the figures are behind a paywall/subscription similar to a number of the NPD Group's information.
Participant rely threads are presently permitted if the participant rely updates are notable and aren't merely updates for the sake of updates (Rule 4). Examples for notable participant rely submissions could be a newly launched sport's participant rely numbers are introduced by a developer or a sport has hit a brand new participant rely file excessive after a substantial time after launch. Participant rely submissions that we’d possible take away for being low-effort or duplicate submissions could be periodic participant rely updates for video games which have stopped receiving help from builders, or a number of participant rely updates shortly after a sport's launch.